Classical Languages - Greek - Foundations - Dialects and Periods

Dialects and Periods
From Homer To The Koine

Dialects and Periods

Prerequisites: Foundations

Next: Morphology

Ancient Greek was never one language. It was spoken for more than a thousand years, in cities that kept their own speech, and its great authors wrote in dialects fixed by their genre as much as by their birthplace. This page gives the reader a map before the paradigms begin: the periods of the language from the Mycenaean tablets to the Koine, the main dialect groups and the genres that used each, the sound changes that separate Attic from the other dialects, and a method for reading a text in a dialect that the grammar does not describe. The grammar takes Attic as its base, and the Homeric dialect, Ionic and the Koine have pages of their own in the section Dialects and verse.

Periods

Stages of Greek

Period Approximate dates Language and main texts
Mycenaean 15th to 12th century BC the Greek of the Linear B tablets from Knossos, Pylos and Mycenae
Dark Age 12th to 9th century BC no written Greek of the usual kind; the alphabet is adopted from the Phoenicians by about 800 to 750 BC
Archaic 8th century to about 480 BC the epic of Homer and Hesiod, the lyric poets, the first inscriptions in local dialects
Classical about 480 to 323 BC Attic of tragedy, comedy, history, philosophy and oratory; the Ionic of Herodotus
Hellenistic 323 to 31 BC the Koine: Polybius, the Septuagint, the papyri
Roman and late antique 31 BC to about AD 600 the Koine, and the Atticising prose of authors such as Plutarch and Lucian
Byzantine and modern after about AD 600 outside the scope of this grammar

The dates are approximate, and the periods overlap. The Homeric poems were composed over a long oral tradition and reached their present form in the eighth and seventh centuries BC, and their language is older than the date of composition.

Writing: Linear B and the alphabet

Linear B is a syllabic script used for accounts on clay tablets in the Mycenaean palaces. Michael Ventris deciphered it in 1952 and showed that the language was Greek, and Greek written some six hundred years before Homer. It preserves forms that later dialects lost: the semivowel w, which Attic dropped, appears in the word that Linear B writes wa-na-ka, later ἄναξ (lord) and in Homer ϝάναξ, a form kept in the metre. Mycenaean has no direct literary descendant, and the grammar does not treat it.

After the collapse of the palaces, the Greeks borrowed the Phoenician alphabet, added vowel signs and spread it, and every region developed its own local variant. The cities used these local alphabets for their inscriptions until the fourth century BC, when the Ionic alphabet that Athens had adopted in 403/402 BC became the standard. The inscriptions are the main evidence for the dialects that left no literature.

Dialects

Dialect groups

A Greek dialect is the speech of a region, and there was no standard language before the Koine. Modern scholarship divides the dialects into four groups.

Group Dialects Region
Ionic–Attic Ionic, Attic the Ionian cities of Asia Minor, Euboea and the Cyclades; Athens and Attica
Aeolic Lesbian, Thessalian, Boeotian the island of Lesbos; Thessaly; Boeotia
West Greek Doric (Laconian, Corinthian, Argive, Cretan, Sicilian), Northwest Greek (Phocian, Locrian, Aetolian, Epirote) the Peloponnese, Crete, the Greek cities of Sicily and southern Italy; central and northwestern Greece
Arcado-Cypriot Arcadian, Cypriot Arcadia; Cyprus

Arcado-Cypriot is the closest to Mycenaean and left only inscriptions. The other three groups account for almost all of Greek literature.

Literary dialects

A Greek author did not write in the speech of his own town. Each genre had its own dialect, which the author learnt as part of the genre, so that the dialect of a work follows the tradition and not the birthplace. Herodotus came from Halicarnassus and wrote in Ionic, Pindar was a Boeotian and wrote choral lyric in a literary Doric, and Hesiod, also a Boeotian, wrote in the dialect of epic.

Genre Dialect Authors
Epic the epic dialect, an artificial blend with an Ionic base, Aeolic elements and older forms Homer, Hesiod
Elegy and iambic poetry Ionic with an epic colouring Archilochus, Mimnermus
Monodic lyric Lesbian Aeolic Sappho, Alcaeus
Choral lyric literary Doric Alcman, Pindar, Bacchylides, and the choral odes of Attic tragedy
Ionic prose Ionic Herodotus, the Hippocratic writers
Attic prose, tragedy and comedy Attic Thucydides, Xenophon, Plato, the orators, Aeschylus, Sophocles, Euripides, Aristophanes
Koine Koine Polybius, the Septuagint, Plutarch

The dialogue of Attic tragedy is in Attic, and the choral odes keep a Doric colouring, with long ᾱ in place of Attic η. Dictionaries mark the dialect of a word with an abbreviation, such as Ep., Ion., Dor., Aeol. and Att.

Specimens

Five passages show the dialects side by side. The features in the last column are the ones that the table in the next section explains.

Dialect Passage Markers
Epic Πηληϊάδεω Ἀχιλῆος (Homer, Iliad 1.1) genitives in -εω and -ῆος, with a single λ in Ἀχιλῆος (Attic Ἀχιλλέως)
Ionic Ἡροδότου Ἁλικαρνησσέος ἱστορίης (Herodotus 1, first sentence) η for the Attic α in ἱστορίης; genitive -έος for Attic -έως
Lesbian Aeolic φαίνεταί μοι κῆνος ἴσος θέοισιν (Sappho, fragment 31, first line) κῆνος for ἐκεῖνος; dative plural θέοισιν for θεοῖς
Doric Ἁδύ τι τὸ ψιθύρισμα καὶ ἁ πίτυς (Theocritus, Idyll 1, first line) long ᾱ in ἁδύ for Attic ἡδύ, and in ἁ for ἡ
Attic Κατέβην χθὲς εἰς Πειραιᾶ (Plato, Republic 327a) εἰς for the older ἐς, and Πειραιᾶ contracted from Πειραιέα

φαίνεταί μοι κῆνος ἴσος θέοισιν

He seems to me equal to the gods. (Sappho, fragment 31, first line; the Lesbian forms are in bold, and the accent of φαίνεταί follows the rule of the proparoxytone before an enclitic, as on the page Accent, proclitics and enclitics)

Ἁδύ τι τὸ ψιθύρισμα καὶ ἁ πίτυς, αἰπόλε, τήνα

Sweet is the whisper of that pine, goatherd. (Theocritus, Idyll 1, first line; the Doric forms are in bold)

Attic and the other dialects

Why Attic is the base

The grammar takes Attic as its base for four reasons.

  1. Attic is the dialect of the largest part of the prose and drama that has survived: Thucydides, Xenophon, Plato, the orators, tragedy and comedy.
  2. The Koine grew out of Attic, with Ionic elements, so that Attic is the starting point of the later language.
  3. Attic is the dialect in which the forms are best known, and the grammars and the dictionaries are built on it.
  4. The other dialects can be described as departures from Attic, and each dialect page of this grammar records only the differences.

Old Attic and later Attic

Attic itself changed between the fifth and the fourth century BC, and a text by an author of the fifth century may have forms that Plato and the orators avoid.

Older Attic (Thucydides, tragedy) Later Attic (Plato, Xenophon, the orators)
ξύν, ξυν- σύν, συν-
ἐς εἰς
θάρσος, ἄρσην θάρρος, ἄρρην

Tragedy also has -σσ- where prose has -ττ-: πράσσω in verse, πράττω in prose. The division is a tendency and not a law, and an edition may print either form.

Attic and Ionic

Attic and Ionic are closely related, and the table gives the main differences. Herodotus is the standard author of literary Ionic, and the page Ionic (Herodotus) treats it in full.

Feature Attic Ionic
Original long ᾱ η, but α after ε, ι, ρ: χώρα, ἡμέρα, σοφία; τιμή η everywhere: χώρη, ἡμέρη, σοφίη
Genitive plural, first declension χωρῶν χωρέων
Dative plural λόγοις, ἡμέραις λόγοισι(ν), ἡμέρῃσι(ν)
Double consonants θάλαττα, γλῶττα θάλασσα, γλῶσσα
ρρ and ρσ θάρρος θάρσος
Contraction ποιῶ, φιλῶ ποιέω, φιλέω (uncontracted)
Interrogative and relative stems ὅπως, ποῖος ὅκως, κοῖος
Initial h kept: ἀφικνέομαι lost in East Ionic (psilosis): ἀπικνέομαι
Reflexive ἑαυτοῦ ἑωυτοῦ

Doric and Aeolic

No page of this grammar treats these dialects, and the features below are the ones a reader of Greek verse meets most often.

  • Doric keeps the original long ᾱ in all positions: μάτηρ against Attic μήτηρ, τιμά against τιμή. The first person plural ends in -μες: λέγομες against λέγομεν. The infinitive ends in -εν: λέγεν.
  • Aeolic (Lesbian) has psilosis, the loss of the rough breathing, and a recessive accent in nouns as well as in verbs. It has π where Attic has τ in πέμπε (five, Attic πέντε), the form ἔμμι for εἰμί, and Μοῖσα for Μοῦσα.

Koine

After the conquests of Alexander (died 323 BC), a common Greek, the κοινὴ διάλεκτος (common dialect), spread over the eastern Mediterranean as the language of administration, trade and literature. It rests on Attic, with Ionic elements and with the simplifications of the spoken language. Its sources are the papyri and the inscriptions, the Septuagint (the Greek translation of the Hebrew scriptures, begun in the third century BC), Polybius, Plutarch, and the New Testament. In the imperial period, the movement called Atticism tried to restore the Attic of the classical authors, and writers such as Lucian imitate the vocabulary and the forms of Plato and Xenophon. Modern Greek descends from the Koine. The page Koine (overview) treats it.

The sound changes of the Koine and of the later language, such as the loss of vowel length and of the pitch accent and the merging of several vowels into [i], are listed in the table of pronunciations on Foundations.

Where the grammar treats the dialects

Page Contents
Homeric forms the morphology of the epic dialect
Homeric syntax and formulae its syntax and its traditional diction
The hexameter and the elegiac couplet the metres of epic and elegy
Ionic (Herodotus) the prose dialect of the Histories
Koine (overview) the common Greek after Alexander

New Testament Greek has no page of its own, and Doric and Aeolic are mentioned but are not treated in full.

Reading a text in an unfamiliar dialect

  1. Identify the genre and the author. The genre usually tells the dialect: epic is the epic dialect, Herodotus is Ionic, choral lyric is literary Doric, Sappho is Lesbian.
  2. Look for the markers. Long α for η, uncontracted vowels, a dative plural in -οισι, κ for π in the interrogatives, and a missing rough breathing are the first signs.
  3. Translate the form into Attic. Restore the contraction, change η to α, restore ττ for σσ, and look up the Attic form, which the dictionary gives.
  4. Check the accent and the metre. In verse the metre often shows which form stands: a long vowel or a short one, an uncontracted syllable that scans as two.
  5. Look at the dictionary label. Liddell and Scott give the dialect of an unusual form.
Ionic or epic Attic Change
Ἁλικαρνησσέος Ἁλικαρνασσέως η for α after ρ, and the genitive ending
ἱστορίης ἱστορίας η for α after ι
ἑωυτοῦ ἑαυτοῦ the Ionic reflexive
Ἀχιλῆος Ἀχιλλέως the epic genitive in -ῆος, with a single λ for the metre

Summary

Topic Rule
Periods Mycenaean, archaic, classical, Hellenistic (Koine), Roman
Dialect groups Ionic–Attic, Aeolic, West Greek, Arcado-Cypriot
Literary dialect follows the genre, not the birthplace
Base of this grammar Attic
Attic against Ionic α against η, contraction, ττ against σσ
Doric long ᾱ, -μες, infinitive in -εν
Aeolic psilosis, recessive accent, π for τ
Koine Attic with Ionic elements, after Alexander

Identification practice

A. Name the dialect of each form and give the Attic equivalent.

  1. χώρη
  2. θάλασσα
  3. μάτηρ
  4. πολέμοιο
  5. ἔμμι
  6. ὅκως
  7. λέγομες
  8. ἡμέρῃσι

B. Give the Attic form.

  1. ἱστορίης
  2. ἑωυτοῦ
  3. ποιέω
  4. ἀπικνέομαι
  5. χωρέων

Answers

A.

  1. Ionic: χώρα.
  2. Ionic (and Koine): θάλαττα.
  3. Doric: μήτηρ.
  4. Epic: πολέμου.
  5. Lesbian Aeolic: εἰμί.
  6. Ionic: ὅπως.
  7. Doric: λέγομεν.
  8. Ionic (and epic): ἡμέραις.

B.

  1. ἱστορίας
  2. ἑαυτοῦ
  3. ποιῶ
  4. ἀφικνέομαι
  5. χωρῶν

Common pitfalls

  • Taking the dialect of a work from the birthplace of its author. Herodotus of Halicarnassus wrote in Ionic, and Pindar of Boeotia wrote in a literary Doric.
  • Treating the epic dialect as a spoken language. It was an artificial literary language, fixed by the demands of the hexameter.
  • Treating Ionic as Attic. The two are close, but the forms in -η, the uncontracted verbs and the -σσ- of Herodotus are not Attic.
  • Expecting Attic forms in tragedy. The dialogue is Attic, but the choral odes have Doric vowels, and the verse has -σσ- where prose has -ττ-.
  • Applying the Attic rules of accent to Aeolic and Doric. The accent of a dialect form may differ from the Attic form.
  • Mixing Old Attic and later Attic. A text of Thucydides has ξύν and ἐς, and one of Plato has σύν and εἰς.
  • Treating the Koine as a decline from Attic. It is a standard language with its own forms and its own literature.

Self-test

  1. In which period does Linear B belong, and who deciphered it?
  2. Name the four groups of Greek dialects.
  3. Why did Herodotus of Halicarnassus write in Ionic?
  4. Why does this grammar take Attic as its base?
  5. Give the Attic forms of χώρη, θάλασσα and ποιέω.
  6. What distinguishes Doric from Attic in μάτηρ and λέγομες?
  7. Which dialect has psilosis and a recessive accent in nouns?
  8. From what dialect does the Koine come?
  9. What was Atticism?
  10. Where does the grammar treat the forms of the epic dialect?

Answers

  1. The Mycenaean period. Michael Ventris deciphered it in 1952.
  2. Ionic–Attic, Aeolic, West Greek (Doric and Northwest Greek), and Arcado-Cypriot.
  3. A dialect follows the genre and not the birthplace, and prose history belonged to the Ionic tradition.
  4. Attic is the dialect of the largest part of the surviving prose and drama, the Koine grew out of it, its forms are best known, and the other dialects can be described as departures from it.
  5. χώρα, θάλαττα, ποιῶ.
  6. Doric keeps the original long ᾱ where Attic has η (μήτηρ), and has -μες for -μεν in the first person plural.
  7. Lesbian Aeolic.
  8. From Attic, with Ionic elements.
  9. A movement of the imperial period that tried to restore the Attic of the classical authors.
  10. On the page Homeric forms.

Next: Morphology

Go to the top of the page